Which of the following is NOT a requirement for a written list of personal property to be valid in a will?

The assertion regarding the requirement for a written list of personal property in a will highlights a key aspect of estate planning. To allow a written list of personal property to complement and clarify a will, it must align with the terms stated in the will. The requirement that the list be consistent with the will ensures that the testator's overall intentions are honored. This consistency is important for avoiding disputes and confusion among beneficiaries regarding the distribution of the testator's belongings.

The other requirements also play a crucial role in the validity of such a list. It must be in the handwriting of the testator to ensure authenticity and clearly demonstrate the intent of the testator. Furthermore, the list must identify items and beneficiaries with certainty, which prevents ambiguity and ensures that the testator's wishes are carried out as intended. The requirement that it must not contradict any other writings permitted by statute safeguards against legal challenges, ensuring that the will and any additional documents are harmonized.

Understanding these requirements reinforces the importance of clarity and the intention of the testator when drafting estate planning documents.